Privacy Mobile Operating Systems
The OldSchool Mobile Directive
Your phone shouldn't spy on you. For robust mobile privacy, specialized operating systems like GrapheneOS, CalyxOS, and PureOS are designed to minimize data collection and enhance security beyond standard iOS and Android.
Top Privacy-Focused Mobile OS
Focus: Widely regarded as the top choice for security and privacy. A hardened version of the Android Open Source Project (AOSP).
Key Features
- Advanced sandboxing for apps with strict isolation
- Enhanced permission model including network and sensors toggles for individual apps
- Exploit mitigations at kernel and memory allocator levels
- No Google services by default but allows sandboxed Google Play Services as unprivileged app for compatibility
- Regular security updates often faster than stock Android
Device Compatibility: Limited to Google Pixel devices (Pixel 8, 9 series, etc.) to ensure tightly integrated hardware/software security, leveraging the Pixel's Titan M2 security chip.
Best For: Security researchers, journalists, activists, anyone requiring maximum mobile privacy and willing to use Pixel hardware.
grapheneos.org
Focus: Balances strong privacy with everyday usability, providing a smoother transition for users accustomed to stock Android.
Key Features
- microG integration - open-source replacement for Google Play Services without full data tracking
- Built-in VPN for network privacy
- Tor Browser included for enhanced anonymity
- Google services don't run in background by default
- Good app compatibility while maintaining privacy
Device Compatibility: Works on various devices including Google Pixel, Fairphone, and select Motorola models.
Best For: Privacy-conscious users who need good app compatibility and don't want to completely abandon Google ecosystem conveniences.
calyxos.org
Focus: A fully open-source, Linux-based operating system that provides an alternative to both Android and iOS ecosystems.
Key Features
- 100% open source - entirely free of proprietary code
- Hardware kill switches to physically disconnect camera, microphone, Wi-Fi, and Bluetooth
- Browser tracker blocking by default
- Complete user control over system and software
- No Google or Apple ecosystem dependency
Device Compatibility: Exclusively available on Purism's own devices (Purism Librem 5, Liberty Phone).
Best For: Privacy purists, free software advocates, users wanting complete independence from big tech ecosystems and willing to invest in specialized hardware.
pureos.net
Focus: Known for broad device support and ability to extend the life of older phones with up-to-date software and security patches.
Key Features
- De-Googled AOSP alternative that's bloatware-free
- Highly customizable with extensive options
- Good privacy controls over app permissions
- Active community with wide device support
- Regular security updates for supported devices
Device Compatibility: Supports a large number of devices from over 20 different brands. Check their device list for your specific phone.
Best For: Users with older devices, those wanting to revive unsupported phones, or anyone needing de-Googled Android on non-Pixel hardware.
Note: Less secure out-of-the-box than GrapheneOS due to fewer security hardening features.
lineageos.org
Feature Comparison
| Operating System |
Basis |
Google Integration |
Security Hardening |
Hardware Kill Switches |
| GrapheneOS |
AOSP (Android) |
None by default; optional sandboxed |
Extensive (kernel, memory, exploits) |
No |
| CalyxOS |
AOSP (Android) |
Optional microG replacement |
Moderate (some tweaks) |
No |
| PureOS |
Linux |
None (no Google apps/tracking) |
Integrated crypto, open-source |
✓ Yes |
| LineageOS |
AOSP (Android) |
None by default (optional GApps) |
Standard Android security |
No |
Mainstream Alternatives
Apple iOS
Pros: Apple's operating system is recognized for strong security due to a tightly controlled, closed ecosystem, robust hardware-software integration, and regular updates. Features like hardware-based encryption, secure enclave, and App Tracking Transparency provide substantial privacy.
Cons: Closed-source system requiring trust in Apple's policies. Apple still collects telemetry and usage data. Not open to independent security audits.
Best For: Users who value convenience and trust Apple, but don't need open-source transparency.
Stock Android (Google Pixel)
Pros: Pixels offer robust security features like the Titan M2 secure chip and long-term security updates (seven years for newer models). Clean Android experience without manufacturer bloatware.
Cons: Stock OS sends significant data to Google's servers. Extensive tracking and telemetry collection. Privacy concerns for highly-conscious users.
Best For: Users who want Google's ecosystem integration and don't mind data collection, or as a base device for installing GrapheneOS/CalyxOS.
OldSchool Recommendations
Maximum Security: GrapheneOS on a Google Pixel device. The gold standard for mobile privacy.
Balanced Privacy: CalyxOS if you need better app compatibility while maintaining strong privacy. Good middle ground.
Complete Freedom: PureOS on Purism hardware if you want 100% open source with hardware kill switches. Requires investment in their devices.
Budget/Compatibility: LineageOS if you have an older device or non-Pixel Android phone. Less secure but better than stock Android.
Mainstream Choice: If you must use mainstream OS, iOS is currently better for privacy than stock Android, though neither match privacy-focused alternatives.
Remember: The best privacy OS is the one you'll actually use. Consider your threat model, technical skill level, and device budget when choosing.
← Back to OldSchool Mobile
View All Services